| 1) |  | Primordial - Spirit the Earth Aflame (2000) | 9.08 (53 votes) |
| 2) |  | Primordial - The Gathering Wilderness (2005) | 9.01 (58 votes) |
| 3) |  | Primordial - The Burning Season (1999) | 9.00 (17 votes) |
| 4) |  | Cruachan - Ride On (2001) | 8.98 (6 votes) |
| 5) |  | Primordial - Storm Before Calm (2002) | 8.97 (37 votes) |
| 6) |  | Cruachan - Folk-Lore (2002) | 8.96 (33 votes) |
| 7) |  | Mourning Beloveth - The Sullen Sulcus (2002) | 8.95 (32 votes) |
| 8) |  | Primordial - A Journey's End (1998) | 8.89 (38 votes) |
| 9) |  | Primordial - Redemption at the Puritan's Hand (2011) | 8.86 (5 votes) |
| 10) |  | Cruachan - A Celtic Trilogy (2002) | 8.84 (3 votes) |
| 11) | Cruachan - Tuatha Na Gael (1995) | 8.80 (34 votes) |
| 12) | Primordial - To The Nameless Dead (2007) | 8.72 (6 votes) |
| 13) | Mourning Beloveth - Dust (2001) | 8.70 (23 votes) |
| 14) | Mourning Beloveth - A Murderous Circus (2005) | 8.63 (21 votes) |
| 15) | Primordial - Where Greater Men Have Fallen (2014) | 8.63 (1 votes) |
| 16) | Primordial - All Empires Fall (video) (2010) | 8.63 (1 votes) |
| 17) | Cruachan - A Celtic Legacy (2007) | 8.63 (1 votes) |
| 18) | Mourning Beloveth - Split with Lunar Gate (2003) | 8.58 (2 votes) |
| 19) | Cruachan - The Middle Kingdom (2000) | 8.57 (31 votes) |
| 20) | Primordial - Imrama (1995) | 8.56 (22 votes) |
| 21) | Primordial - Exile Amongst the Ruins (2018) | 8.54 (1 votes) |
| 22) | Cruachan - Pagan (2004) | 8.50 (12 votes) |
| 23) | Graveyard Dirt - Shadows of Old Ghosts (2007) | 8.45 (1 votes) |
| 24) | Cruachan - Celtica (demo) (1994) | 8.45 (1 votes) |
| 25) | Graveyard Dirt - For Grace Or Damnation (2010) | 8.33 (2 votes) |
